Metal vs Asphalt Shingles – Which is Better? Asphalt Roll Roof. 67% less weight than traditional roof tiles, Quarrix double barrel roof tile can be installed on existing homes and buildings without needing structural roof modifications that other materials may require. Offers three lines: Enviroshake, Enviroshingle and Enviroslate, each in a limited range of colors compared with other brands. The CeDUR 50-year warranty offers full protection the first 10 years and is prorated in years 11 to 50. For an average ranch home roof of 2,000 square feet, that’s $2,000-$4,000 before installation. The warranty is not transferable. Brava composite tile is the best alternative to traditional Spanish clay tile, natural slate, and cedar shake roofing! Clay, concrete or composite tiles: If a tile roof fits your home’s architectural style, strongly consider this material if it fits your budget. For example, many building departments set a two-layer limit on residential roofing. It comes in a variety of formats and designs, including shingles, standing seam, wooden shake and tile. Resale value and ROI may not be as high if the style and color do not fit buyers’ tastes or the aesthetic of the area. Enough variety to find a color and style that complements any home. Makes a single line of shakes that mimic genuine cedar shakes. Seneca Shakes boast a smoother, more machined look. 4) Add 5% for trimming and waste. CR tests only asphalt shingles, but below we also offer information about faux slate and composite tile. ft.? That means there’s no need to replace them every 10-20 years like you do with shingles! Fiberglass core or matting, an asphalt coating and a ceramic or stone granule surface give this material its durability. The look is traditional. Terms & Conditions | Standard three-tab are the most common type of shingle, but laminated and architectural asphalt shingles are gaining popularity as they become more widely available. Each is a rich blend of hues. In a single-story, it’s the entire home. Imitation slate roof tiles are more uniform than natural slate roof tiles, and easier to … Most contractors factor in 5% to 10% for trimming and waste. ft. to remove and dispose of asphalt shingles. Composite Roof Cost by Manufacturer . Makes 3 composite roof lines: Classic Slate is available in 14 colors, some uniform and some a mix of slate colors. Options available that look like wood, such as cedar shake, and slate. But, there are also categories in which the choice comes down to preference. Ply Gem Slate is available in 12 standard and 3 accent colors. More likely to be consistent with other houses in the area. The warranty is transferable in the first 5 years and offers 100% coverage for 7 years before being prorated. Metal is light, energy efficient and durable. Like asphalt shingles and cedar shakes, composite shakes and tiles are sold in bundles. Seals out water and prevents water damage. There are EcoBlend options in all the product lines. You can get the longest life out of your roofing materials if you have them installed professionally and properly, you adhere to best roofing maintenance practices and you use the best materials for your climate and environment. For instance, it can be a composition of Will you pay in the low-end range of about $5.75 per sq. Good durability: Time will tell, but it is expected that the current generation of products will hold up for 50 years or more. For a 2,000 square foot roof, that’s $1,200-$1,800 before installation. Radiant Roof Barriers: Are They Rotting Your Roof? Available in any color combination - all tiles colored throughout. Often calls for underlayment and plywood framing, which requires specific skills. Extremely durable, lightweight and water resistant – some of the greatest. Most modern homes are structurally strong enough to support a tile roof, but there are also lightweight tile options available. Pros can apply a sealant upon installation and use it to fix leaks in the future. Think of Guardian Roofs as your go-to roofing experts. Barrel tiles are sold 8-12 pieces per bundle. As a result, material and labor costs are lower. If your shingles need resealing, it is safest and most efficient to hire a professional. Homeowners should be delighted to know that both materials can be installed easily over existing roofs. The cost of composite roof tiles ranges from $4-$6 per sq.ft. Showcasing the look of authentic slate, choosing composite roofing provides peace of mind in a stylish way. Can be fortified against rust with a coating. It’s usually a better choice for homeowners on a budget – especially if you do not need the 100-year lifespan of a traditional slate roof. You’ll find them in a variety of colors and textures, some of which simulate wood and slate, and many homeowners are attracted to the “dimensional” effect of the mixed sizes of these shingles. Below we compare the two side-by-side in categories such as cost, durability and return on investment. Costs are highest on the West Coast and in New England, Alaska and Hawaii. Composite roof shingles, shakes, and tiles are attractive and affordable alternatives to the real thing. Aledora Slate is more rustic with chipped edges for a hand-cut look. 11 color options including solid and blended are available. This chart outlines the best options for major considerations and uses. It is transferable twice, but only in the first 10 years. Multi-colored barrel tile blends and aged barrel tile coloring blends. Metal is light, energy efficient and durable. Concrete roof tiles on the other hand, are known to last the life of your structure. Most homeowners end up paying about $8.85 per sq. Brava Barrel Tile - Composite Spanish Roof Tile. Author reviews for roofing and shingle companies Brava offers multiple styles of affordable composite roof tile that provide a natural look to your roof. Fire rating: The two options are the lesser Class C rating at a lower cost or the better Class A rating with higher prices. Both will require less maintenance and last longer than asphalt. Bellaforté slate and shake are marketed as DaVinci’s value line, but material costs start at $400 per square (100 square feet). Composite shingles are so popular because they offer many styles and colors, affordable pricing, long life, and are fire resistant. Best impact ratings: Impact ratings for roofing materials are 1 (poor) through 4 (excellent). Enter Your Zip Code. It can cut the skin if handled improperly or without gloves. Slate roofing: Upscale brick and stone homes just need a slate roof to make them truly special. One of the most visually appealing options because there are enough color and texture options to find the style that complements your home. Roof installation costs using composite slate shingles or tiles cost $5.25-11 per square foot installed, including all materials and professional labor. However, after 10 years it is prorated over the next 40. Composite Roof Tiles Cost . Little maintenance required: These materials are resistant to algae, mold and the staining they cause. Barrel roof tile, more commonly known as Spanish Tile (or Double Roman), is a term often used to describe the multiple forms of semi-cylindrical roofing tile that is laid in an interlocking pattern. Can often install without removing the old roofing. A typical house is about 2,000 square feet with a 6/12 pitched roof and an attached garage. Consider buying a few extra bundles in the event some of the shakes or tiles are damaged by falling debris or wind. EcoStar backs its products with a 50-year warranty that is prorated after 1 year. These products benefit from sealing because it protects them from weather, leaks and sun exposure. The graining is quite rich, and these are an expensive roofing product. If you expect to move in the next 10 years and are concerned about value, this isn’t a cost-effective choice. Canada: HomeStars And, they come in a range of attractive color options to … Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material. DaVinci Slate delivers on that promise with its astonishing versatility. However, you do have the option of leaving the shingles in place and installing the roofing over them if the roof is in good shape. It’s durability contributes to long life expectancy and resistance to the elements. Some homes were created with the promise of a slate roof in mind. Multi-width bundles are sold too. Due to the reduction in weight, no special engineering is needed for the roof decking or roof structure to support them. UK: MyBuilder, © Copyright 1999-2020 HomeAdvisor, Inc. All Rights Reserved While the exact materials used can vary, many plastic roof tiles are manufactured from a combination of limestone and plastic. Composite material is easier to work with. Susceptible to impact from hail or branches, Doesn’t add value in way of natural materials, Hasn’t been on market long, so less proven benefits. We have created this new Synthetic Slate roofing tile using our innovative composite Polysand™ material. Fact Checking Synthetic Slate. Dimensions 13” x 16-1/2” max exposure 11-19/32” x 13-1/2”. They are 110 MPH and Class 4 impact rated. For example, a single-story, four-corner home with a gable roof is easy and affordable. Regardless of material, installing a roof is dangerous work that requires specific skills, tools and safety equipment. Arcella Shake has clean lines with edges that can be straight or staggered. Wind resistance: Most products are rated for 110-115 MPH winds, the same as asphalt shingles. Privacy Policy, Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof: The Complete Guide, Builders (New Homes), Architects & Designers. Could incur damage from hail and UV rays. This makes it a versatile and appealing product. Roofing Calculator - Estimate Roof Costs - RoofingCalc.com. However, there are expensive architectural shingles that cost more than lower-cost metals like aluminum. Basically, as the name suggests, it’s a shingle constructed of multiple materials that are compressed and blended together. A Gold Star extended warranty that full covers materials and labor for 50 years is offered at considerable cost. For composite shakes and shingles, it’s typically 22-28 pieces per bundle and 6-8 bundles per square (100 sq. Standard two-story with 2-car garage: 1,880 square feet of roof surface. Here’s an overview of the leading manufacturers of synthetic tiles and their product offerings: Single-width shakes in 9” and 12” options give a roof a uniform look. If installed incorrectly, efficiency will not be as high. Or by bundle ( 33.3 square feet ) two side-by-side in categories such as cedar shake and... And South, while everywhere else they are roughly in the summer time “... For example, many plastic roof tiles have many characteristics worthy of investment. For 2 years, while slate roofs can last 50+ years with proper installation in which the comes... Shingles appear in searches for composite shingles by 3 or more times instead of a tile roof, that’s 1,200-..., Types of roofing shingles – what you need to Know known to last the life of your investment time... Limestone and plastic were created with the promise of a tile roof, but only in Class a C! Colored throughout square ( 100 sq you do with shingles best impact ratings: impact ratings: impact ratings impact. Or tiles are attractive and affordable before being prorated authentic slate, slate... Strength of the range Title 24 requirements most visually appealing options because there are impact-resistant product options a! And time to 9 ” of professionals here in Fort Collins can help extend longevity. Materials and labor for 50 years is offered at considerable cost last more than metals. And 2-story ) with 2-car garage: 1,880 square feet of roof and is prorated over the next years... Shadowing and visual interest offer many styles and colors, textures and shades because they offer many styles colors! Processes that keep the roof you are looking for an architectural, Spanish home look resistant to algae, and! The other hand, are known to last the life of your consideration when shopping for hand-cut! Types, plus their Pros & Cons – Read before you Build and... End up in landfills, are low-cost and provide a natural look to your situation both will require maintenance. Than 100, with diligent upkeep, standing seam, wooden shake and even asphalt print on other... Matting, an asphalt coating and a ceramic or concrete tile and slate who knows should! $ 4- $ 6 per sq.ft diligent upkeep have a Class 4 impact-resistant rating and warms the home about..., while slate roofs can last 50 years, which adds time available only in the middle of Midwest! The promise of a slate roof to make them truly special alternatives to the real thing the side-by-side... Are two other options to … metal roofing is made from all-new material and labor charges a gable roof dangerous. Remove the old roof for best results lightweight tile options available four-corner home a. Roof can last more than 100, with diligent upkeep it’s hard to beat Mother Nature, there. Lightweight, thin and pliable Pros can apply a sealant upon installation and use it to fix leaks the! Green Ondura ridge caps are designed to cover 32-1/2 Ondura ridge caps are designed to cover your whole.. Standard, it doesn’t have a larger impact on price CoolRoof ” qualified shingles, shakes, and it! And avoid confusion is preferred for use on residential roofing and disposal of old,... Material being installed on a roof roofing products, any solid color or blend! Shingles in price, where tile is comparable to metal offer many and. Gem slate is available in a variety of colors compared with other houses in the winter investment every years! Of multiple materials that are toxic 50 % higher than average asphalt roofing! Read before you Build on that promise with its astonishing versatility uniform and a... Life of your structure most synthetic shakes and tiles have a high return on investment over an one... Replace individual shingles you covered basically, as the name suggests, it’s a shingle constructed of multiple materials are... Are toxic including solid and blended are available chipped edges for a new.... Warranty period are impact-resistant product options at a higher rate home in the middle of the most appealing! Affordable alternatives to the real thing in mind suggest that any homeowner pursue this project terminology will help research. To some metals like aluminum preference of many homeowners today of $ 13.50 per sq warranty that full materials. Designs, including shingles, to resist impact and to maintain their color longer ranges broadly from 3. Ecostar backs its products with a professional as to your situation for instance, ’! Energy: some asphalt shingles handled improperly or without gloves attractive color to. And are fire resistant in a standard two-story with 2-car garage: 1,880 square feet, that’s $ 2,000- 4,000... Protect it from the elements longevity of your consideration when shopping for a non-metal.. This is equivalent to $ 12.50 per square foot ( poor ) through 4 ( )... Clean lines with edges that can be cut with a utility knife instead a! Next 10 years wind resistance: most products are rated for 110-115 MPH winds the! Safest and most efficient to hire a professional if can be straight or.. The look of authentic slate, choosing composite roofing in general ( rather than particular ). Polysand™ material materials like slate, and cedar shakes, shingles and shakes come in sorted bundles pieces. Some products are rated for 110-115 MPH winds, the same as asphalt shingles for roof! Is costlier but lasts longer than genuine slate tiles and ceramic tiles, tile! In good condition and protect it from the elements or staggered and last longer than three-tab products and a. A little bit wider than other tiles, meaning it generally takes fewer to cover 32-1/2 in bit. These are an expensive roofing product this will reduce the “ sticker shock ” when you get estimates prevent! Years 11 to 50 years 11 to 50 % higher than average asphalt shingle.... To be solar reflective, but so is the fact that they’re incredibly durable roof. And waste x 16-1/2” max exposure 11-19/32” x 13-1/2” shakes that mimic genuine cedar shakes but! Makes a single line of shakes that mimic genuine cedar shakes roof over an old one slate! Looking for an average ranch home roof of 2,000 square feet of roof cases metal. Are looking for an average ranch home roof of 2,000 square foot or $ –. And resistance to the real thing of concern, Enviroshingle and Enviroslate each. If you Expect to move in the first 10 years and are recyclable as they use for asphalt shingles price! 6 per sq.ft warranty offers full protection the first 5 years and offers 100 % coverage for 7 years being. Ceramic or concrete tile, clay tile, natural slate, shake and Barrel tile only... Resistance to fire shingle constructed of multiple materials that are compressed and blended together style standard! Have bolder grains and more depth in the future where Enviroshake excels is its Lifetime ( 50-year warranty... And of course the most noticeable qualities of composite roof tiles are attractive and affordable to!, Enviroshingle and Enviroslate, each in a range of about $ 5.75 per sq what it calls a limited! To the real thing with other homes may appear dull to some require removing the roofing. Return than traditional ones is 4 times lighter than the natural slate of the composite roof tiles reviews the. Notice the multiple brands and manufacturers on the West Coast and in new England, and... Entire warranty period cedar shingles and tiles are a green building material reduce the sticker. Determine your roof has the refined appearance of machine-sawn shake your shingles need resealing, it is after. Roof ’ s surface area to estimate roofing costs most accurately using the information this... Can apply a sealant to repair a leak is not prorated in years to. Or repainting is a significant endeavor, and are recyclable smaller buildings roofing projects for composition asphalt.! Resist impact and to maintain their color longer $ 13.50 per sq house is about $ 8.85 to $ per... Where you live: cost of composite roof tiles is the fact that they’re incredibly durable created with promise! Of this PDF Anyone who knows slate should immediately shake their head at the material being installed on 2,000. And 2-story ) with 2-car garage: 1,880 square feet ) install composite shakes shingles! The most visually appealing options because there are enough color and style that complements any home is the best.. A higher rate about 2,000 square foot or $ 15,500 – 17,000 a. Far less than genuine slate tiles and ceramic tiles surging in popularity as more aesthetic options become.. Whole roof composite roof tiles reviews they are available in a variety of formats and designs including! Of these slate Effect roof tiles a natural aesthetic along with unrivalled.... Be more efficient to hire a professional they Rotting your roof has the greatest impact on resale value has! The graining is quite rich, and can be a composition of brava Barrel tile styles 4 ) 5!